Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY- Caledonia, NY Exposed: PDI failures, delivery defects, F&I upsell traps

Introduction: What We Found About Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY (Caledonia, NY)

AI-powered research tools have systematically collected and analyzed public information to produce this report. The focus is Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY, located in Caledonia, NY, which services the greater Rochester region. This dealership operates as part of the multi-location Meyer’s RV Superstores network, a regional chain with stores across New York and nearby states. While the brand benefits from broad inventory and name recognition, public feedback for the Caledonia location points to recurring consumer pain points—especially around service timelines, delivery quality, sales pressure, paperwork delays, and post-sale support.

Because real-world owner experiences are critical when evaluating any RV dealership, we strongly encourage you to read recent consumer reviews for yourself. Start with the dealership’s Google Business profile, and use the “Sort by Lowest Rating” filter to see the newest and most critical complaints first: Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY (Caledonia) — Google Business Profile.

How to Do Your Own Homework Before You Visit

Unfiltered owner communities and real user videos

• Search and watch consumer exposés: The Liz Amazing YouTube channel regularly investigates RV industry pitfalls. Search her channel for the exact dealership or brand you’re considering to learn common failure points and buyer protection strategies.
• Use Facebook brand groups for owner-to-owner feedback: Don’t rely on dealership marketing. Join multiple model-specific owner groups to see maintenance threads, warranty fights, and repair timelines. Use this Google search to find active communities: Find RV brand Facebook groups.
• Scan forums and subreddit history: Owner forums and subreddits often flag recurring issues by make and model years. We’ve listed links later in this report to speed up your research.

Have you already bought or serviced with Meyer’s RV of Rochester? Add your first-hand account in the comments to help others.

Before You Buy: Arrange an Independent RV Inspection

Across many dealerships—including those with large inventories—customers repeatedly report taking delivery only to discover water leaks, electrical faults, miswired brake controllers, propane leaks, non-functioning appliances, and structural issues that should have been caught during pre-delivery inspection (PDI). The only real leverage a buyer has is before signing or taking the unit off the lot. Hire a third-party NRVIA-certified inspector to perform a complete, documented inspection. If the dealer doesn’t allow a professional third-party inspection, that’s a major red flag—walk away.

• Find local inspectors with a quick search: RV Inspectors near me.
• Require a written punch list from the inspector and insist repairs are completed—documented in writing—before final payment.
• Remember: once the sale is complete, your RV may join a long service queue. Many buyers on public forums describe delayed camping plans—or entire seasons lost—waiting on parts and service after purchase.

Not sure what to look for? Videos from consumer advocates like Liz Amazing can help you understand crucial inspection points and how to hold sellers accountable.

What Recent Public Feedback Suggests About the Caledonia Location

Below are the dominant issue patterns that repeatedly surface in low-star public reviews, forum posts, and consumer complaints concerning Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY in Caledonia. We encourage you to verify by sorting the Google Business reviews by lowest rating: Read the latest 1- and 2-star reviews.

Sales Tactics and Pricing Transparency

Patterns described in recent low-star reviews include aggressive sales follow-ups, shifting price figures between initial quote and finance office, and surprise add-ons (such as “prep fees,” “protection packages,” or mandatory orientation charges). Buyers allege that advertised prices sometimes balloon with dealer-installed extras they did not request.

• Pressure to “hold” a unit with non-refundable deposits before a thorough walkthrough.
• Bundled products (paint protection, fabric guard, nitrogen tires) presented as standard, adding hundreds or thousands to out-the-door price.
• Discrepancies between online listing details and actual equipment on the lot.

Protect yourself by asking for a full, itemized buyers’ order with all fees, and get a “no additional add-ons” statement in writing. If a unit’s advertised price doesn’t match the contract without extras, be ready to walk.

High-Interest Loans and Questionable Add-Ons in F&I

Multiple consumers describe finance-office surprises: dealer markups on interest rates compared to pre-approvals, hard-to-cancel extended service contracts, and complex “warranty” or “lifetime” packages with unclear coverage. Some allege they were told add-ons were required for financing approval—an illegal practice.

• Obtain your own financing from a bank or credit union before visiting.
• Decline every add-on first; agree only after you’ve read full contracts and compared third-party alternatives.
• Verify cancellation terms in writing. Some “warranties” have strict claim hurdles or reimbursement-only terms that disappoint owners.

For broader context on upsells and protecting yourself, review consumer-focused content on channels like Liz Amazing’s RV buyer protection videos.

Trade-In Valuations and Low-Ball Offers

Trade-in disputes are common across the RV industry. Public feedback at the Caledonia location reflects claims of unexpectedly low trade valuations that shift after appraisal, or reductions discovered late in the paperwork process. Owners report feeling rushed to accept diminished offers to avoid losing the unit they want.

• Get third-party appraisals and local consignment quotes before visiting.
• Never rely on verbal promises; require written, VIN-specific trade-in quotes with expiration dates.
• If numbers change in the finance office, pause the process and compare your options.

Paperwork, Titles, and Registration Delays

Public reviews often flag slow title processing and registration, with buyers stuck unable to legally tow or camp. Some report paying for delivery only to wait weeks for plates or corrected documents, and struggling to get responsive updates.

• Ensure lienholder data, VIN, and odometer statements are correct before you leave.
• Ask for realistic timing in writing. If you’re out of state, confirm reciprocity and tax handling in advance.
• Document every communication and maintain a paper trail.

Delivery Condition and PDI (Pre-Delivery Inspection) Quality

Numerous low-star reviews describe taking delivery only to find significant defects: water intrusion, non-functional slides, inoperable refrigerators or HVAC, damaged seals, loose trim, and missing parts. Several accounts say issues were obvious during pickup day but weren’t addressed due to scheduling or “bring it back later” responses.

• Insist on a comprehensive PDI checklist, completed and signed, with corrective actions documented before you accept the unit.
• Perform a water test: run faucets, shower, toilet, and tank fill; inspect under sinks and in storage bays for leaks.
• Plug into shore power and run every appliance, AC, and heater. Test slides, awnings, stabilizers, and leveling systems multiple times.
• Hire a third-party inspector: Find RV inspectors near me.

Service Department Backlogs and Warranty Navigation

One of the most frequent complaints in public forums and reviews is long waits for service appointments, parts delays, and poor communication during warranty work. Buyers report units sitting for weeks—or months—especially during peak season, sometimes with minimal status updates.

• Confirm whether the Caledonia service center prioritizes customers who purchased at this location over outside units.
• Ask what their current average turnaround is on warranty repairs, and get that answer in writing.
• Request that the service advisor provide a promised update schedule (e.g., weekly) and a single point of contact.
• Keep copies of all signed work orders and service notes for warranty enforcement.

Readers who have navigated service at this location: What was your turnaround time?

Communication Gaps and Unkept Promises

Customers frequently cite misaligned expectations: promises made on the sales floor that don’t carry through to the service bay, slow callbacks, and difficulty reaching the right staff member. This erodes trust, especially when paired with serious repair needs or warranty coverage questions.

• Move critical discussions to email for an auditable trail.
• Summarize agreements in writing and ask staff to confirm via reply—before you sign.
• Set specific timelines and escalation points if commitments are missed.

Quality of Workmanship on Post-Sale Repairs

Even when repairs are performed, some reviewers report disappointing outcomes: recurring leaks, repeat electrical faults, or cosmetic fixes that don’t address root causes. Customers also note inconsistent technician expertise for certain makes or systems.

• Request photos and parts numbers with any repair order so you can verify work completed.
• If a fix fails, ask to escalate to the service manager and the OEM’s regional rep. Persistently failing repairs can strengthen your warranty claims.
• Consider a second opinion from an independent mobile technician—often faster than waiting in line during peak season.

Unnecessary Upsells and “Protection Plans”

From tire-and-wheel coverage to fabric and paint sealants, many add-ons are priced high relative to their benefit. Reviewers often feel these were presented as “must-have” or mandatory. These products can be legitimate for some owners, but policies vary widely and may exclude common RV failure modes.

• Excel at saying “no” until you’ve compared independent products and read exclusions.
• Ask for the full contract in advance and review at home.
• Confirm cancelability and refund pro-rating in writing.

To minimize risk, arrive with financing and extended coverage decisions already researched—advice echoed by consumer advocates on channels like Liz Amazing.

Evidence and Research: Verify What You Read

Use the links below to gather direct-source information about “Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY Caledonia NY.” Replace “Issues” with “Problems,” “Complaints,” or a specific topic when helpful. Always sort by newest content and weigh patterns over isolated anecdotes.

• YouTube search: Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY Caledonia NY Issues
• Google search: Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY Caledonia NY Issues
• BBB search: Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY Caledonia NY
• Reddit r/RVLiving: Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY Caledonia NY Issues
• Reddit r/GoRVing: Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY Caledonia NY Issues
• Reddit r/rvs: Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY Caledonia NY Issues
• NHTSA recalls portal (then search by brand/model)
• RVInsider search
• Good Sam Community forum search
• RVForums.com (use the site search for “Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY Caledonia NY”)
• RVForum.net (search for dealership name + issues)
• RVUSA forums (use header search for dealership issues)
• PissedConsumer (enter dealership name in site search)

If you’ve looked up any of these sources, what stood out to you?

Legal and Regulatory Warnings

Warranty Rights and Deceptive Practices

Consumers who experience warranty denials or misleading sales claims should be aware of the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, which protects buyers of consumer products against deceptive warranty practices. Details: FTC: Guide to Federal Warranty Law. If you are told a warranty claim isn’t covered without clear, written justification, escalate with the manufacturer and document everything.

Loan and Add-On Compliance

It is unlawful for a dealer to require specific add-ons to secure financing or to misrepresent loan terms. If you believe you were misled in the finance office, complaints can be filed with the Federal Trade Commission: ReportFraud.FTC.gov.

State-Level Assistance (New York)

For disputes involving alleged deceptive practices, contract issues, or titled-vehicle concerns, contact the New York State Attorney General: NY Attorney General Consumer Frauds Bureau. New York also has lemon-law style protections, though RVs can be complex since the “house” portion and the “vehicle” portion may be treated differently; consult an attorney for RV-specific applicability.

Safety Defects and Recalls

If you encounter safety-related defects—brakes, tires, steering, fuel system, LP gas leaks, electrical fires—file a report with NHTSA. You can search active recalls by brand and model, then report problems if they’re not yet covered by a recall: NHTSA Recalls Search. You can also start from our earlier link and then refine by your RV’s make/model.

Product and Safety Impact Analysis

Reported Delivery Defects and Real-World Consequences

Water intrusion at delivery can mean hidden mold, delamination, and rotted subfloors—major depreciation and potential health risk. Electrical miswiring or undersized fuses can create fire hazards. Faulty brake controllers or compromised bearings can cause catastrophic towing failures. When such issues are reported immediately after purchase and the unit sits for weeks awaiting parts or technician time, owners can miss entire travel windows or suffer campsite cancellation penalties.

• Conduct your own leak checks and thermal imaging if possible.
• Verify LP system integrity with a manometer test and a bubble leak test.
• Ensure brake and light checks with your tow vehicle before leaving the lot.

A professional inspection prior to purchase is not optional—treat it as essential. Use this search to identify specialists: Independent RV inspectors in your area.

Delayed Repairs and Financial Risk

Even when a warranty covers the fix, delays can translate to out-of-pocket costs: storage, alternate lodging, trip changes, and lost deposits. Owners sometimes face repeated trips to the dealership if root causes aren’t corrected the first time. Track all costs and consider seeking reimbursement through the OEM when delays are unreasonable.

Balancing the Record: Any Positives?

Public feedback isn’t uniformly negative. Some buyers report positive sales experiences and friendly staff at the Caledonia store, smooth deliveries, or successful warranty resolutions. Large dealerships can have variability between departments and across time. Management responses to online reviews indicate a willingness to engage on certain issues. Nonetheless, the volume and consistency of serious complaints—especially around service delays, PDI misses, paperwork, and upsells—demand extra vigilance and rigorous pre-purchase safeguards.

If you’ve had a notably positive or negative experience, can you document what went right or wrong? Your details help others.

Action Checklist for Shoppers Considering Meyer’s RV of Rochester (Caledonia, NY)

• Verify online reviews: Use “Sort by Lowest Rating” on the Google Business profile to see recent problem patterns.
• Demand a complete PDI with documentation: Do not take delivery if essential systems aren’t proven to work. Put all repair commitments in writing.
• Bring your own financing and coverage decisions: Compare bank/credit union rates and research third-party warranties to avoid high-pressure upsells.
• Insist on a third-party inspection: Independent confirmation is your leverage. If it’s refused, walk.
• Get every number in writing: Itemized out-the-door price, specific trade-in value, cancellation terms, and any “We promise to do X” commitments.
• Plan for service realities: Ask about current service backlogs and whether this store prioritizes in-house customers over outside purchases.
• Follow industry watchdogs: Search channels like Liz Amazing for buyer protections and dealership reputation research.

Frequently Alleged Issues at This Location—And How to Mitigate

“The price changed in finance”

Mitigation: Request a buyers’ order with every fee before you meet F&I. Decline all add-ons by default. Bring a pre-approval from your lender.

“Delivery day revealed obvious problems”

Mitigation: Block out half a day for the PDI and bring your own inspection checklist. Don’t finalize payment until repairs are completed.

“Service kept my RV for weeks with little communication”

Mitigation: Before you leave the unit, require a written estimate, target dates, and a weekly update commitment. Escalate to the service manager and the manufacturer if deadlines slip.

“Title/registration delays derailed our travel plans”

Mitigation: Confirm paperwork is correct at signing and ask for clear timelines. If out-of-state, verify tax and registration handling before you pay.

Final Perspective on Risk

Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY in Caledonia benefits from being part of a larger dealership network with access to inventory and financing options. However, publicly documented experiences show recurring risks that are costly and disruptive: delivery defects that should have been caught by PDI, long service delays, add-on pricing pressure, shifting numbers in finance, title and registration lag, and uneven communication.

The safest path is disciplined due diligence. Vet the specific VIN you’re buying, arrange an independent inspection, and put everything in writing. If any step feels rushed or opaque, be prepared to walk and keep shopping. Comparable RVs are available across the region, and your leverage is strongest before you sign. If you’ve recently purchased or serviced at this Caledonia location, would you share what happened so others can learn from it?

Bottom Line Recommendation

Given the volume and consistency of serious complaints around delivery quality, service delays, and finance/upsell pressure at Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY (Caledonia), we do not recommend rushing into a purchase here. Proceed only with a third-party inspection, firm written terms, and a willingness to walk away if transparency or cooperation is lacking. Many buyers may be better served by comparing other dealerships with stronger documented service performance and fewer delivery-day surprises.

Comments: Real Buyer Experiences

Have you bought or serviced an RV at Meyer’s RV of Rochester NY in Caledonia? Your first-hand details—positive or negative—help fellow RVers avoid costly mistakes. Please include dates, model, how issues were handled, and the final outcome.